News & Insights

Home » News & Insights » Update: Judicial Ruling Brings Broker Fee Ban to Swift Halt

Update: Judicial Ruling Brings Broker Fee Ban to Swift Halt


by Bill Oxford, from Unsplash

A New York judge ruled against New York’s surprise broker fee ban on Monday, reversing last week’s shock announcement. The ruling came after the real estate industry filed a lawsuit against the Department of State, alleging the agency “usurped” the state legislature and engaged in inappropriate rule-making. Ruling in favor of the plaintiffs, the judge issued a temporary restraining order that will allow broker fees to continue being collected. The Department of State will have a chance to respond in court on March 13 in its effort to implement this new rule. Although the situation remains fluid, it appears that many observers of the rule change last week were correct to hone in on the question of whether regulators had overstepped the text of last year’s Tenant Protection Act in creating this rule or whether its language was sufficiently broad to permit this type of additional regulation. [1]

[1] Haag, M. (February 2020) Sorry, Renters: You Still Have to Pay Brokers’ Fees for Now from NY Times Accessed February 11 2020

Recent Posts

Is Your Co-Op or Condo ADA Compliant?

A shareholder in your co-op has recently become disabled and your building’s entrance is not fully accessible. Is the co-op responsible for modifying the entrance so it accommodates the disabled resident? Accommodations required by Title III of the American...

Should You Buy a Condo or Co-op Through an LLC?

Buying an apartment through a Limited Liability Company or LLC may be a way to limit personal liability or protect assets, but it may not be a viable option.  Even if it is, it might not be worth the trouble. In the first instance, the purchase of a cooperative...

Can Adult Children of Co-Op Shareholders Live in the Unit?

When it comes to allowing adult children to live in a co-op without the shareholder, a host of questions come into play, including the co-op’s rules about subletting and the terms of the proprietary lease. In a prior post about subletting a co-op, we explained that...