News & Insights

Home » News & Insights » Palin’s Lawsuit Tossed: Op-Ed Process Protected

Palin’s Lawsuit Tossed: Op-Ed Process Protected

Legal Developments

“The New York Times Building” by JavierDo, licensed under CC Attribution Share Alike 3.0 Unported.

 Today, SDNY Judge Jed S. Rakoff  dismissed a defamation lawsuit filed by the former vice-presidential candidate Sarah Palin against The New York Times, over an allegedly defamatory op-ed piece that Palin claimed inaccurately linked her to a mass shooting in 2011 that injured former congresswoman Gabby Giffords. The Times piece incorrectly drew a link between the shooter and a map circulated by the Palin PAC that showed certain congressional districts superimposed by crosshairs.

Rakoff’s dismissal was based largely on the ground that Palin’s complaint failed to show that the NY Times’ mistakes were made ” maliciously” instead of being the result of haste and even negligence.

Earlier this month, Judge Rakoff held an admittedly “unusual” hearing  to give what he called “context” to the Times‘ editorial processes as he weighed the motion by the NY Times to dismiss Palin’s  suit. Times editorial page editor and author of the controversial portions of the piece, James Bennet, had taken the court through a detailed dissection of the editorial that the former VP candidate claims was defamatory.

Bennet insisted he did not intend to imply a “causal link” between the 2011 mass shooting and the controversial  “crosshairs” map distributed by a Sarah Palin PAC.  Bennet said he in no way meant to suggest that shooter “was acting because of this map.” Judge Rakoff was apparently persuaded by the testimony as well as the paper’s subsequent corrections, finding: “Such behavior is much more plausibly consistent with making an unintended mistake and then correcting it than with acting with actual malice.”

The Judge’s opinion reinforces the protections that allow editorial authors leeway to write “rapidly” on immediate events of “importance,” even if such quick actions result in errors.

Recent Posts

Impact of Shorter COVID-19 Quarantine on Workplaces

On Monday, the CDC announced changes to its recommended isolation and quarantine time from 10 days to 5 days for asymptomatic people with COVID-19. They recommend that people leaving isolation after 5 days continue to wear a mask for the following 5 days. The CDC also...

Restaurants Sue Over Vaccine Mandate

Restaurant operators sued Mayor Bill de Blasio and New York City over Key to NYC, the new indoor vaccine mandate program, on August 17-the same day the mandate went into effect. A group of restaurants in Staten Island, through the Independent Restaurant Owners...

Financial Regulators’ New Target: Social Media Influencers and SPACs

The Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (“FINRA”) will conduct three new regulatory sweeps in an effort to combat various activities causing extreme fluctuations in the financial markets. FINRA has chosen to target special purpose acquisition companies (“SPACs”),...

Does WARN Apply to Virus Closures?

Enterprise, in Benson et al. v. Enterprise Leasing Co. of Florida LLC et al., has tried to argue that the Worker Adjustment and Retraining Notification Act (“WARN”), through its natural disaster exception, does not apply to closures caused by COVID-19. Two Florida...